This photo of dead tree stumps, taken by Noah Williams, illustrates the ravages on the land and vegetation of the Owens Valley resulting from a century of combined surface water diversion and groundwater pumping by the L.A. Department of Water & Power.
“When you remove the water from the land, you remove life. The surface water diversion not only halted our irrigation practices we used for subsistence, it also contributed to the loss of habitat across the valley, most notably, the loss of Owens Lake. Our Elders tell stories of digging a couple of feet in our own backyards and reaching water,” Williams said. “Now, because of L.A., the average groundwater depth beneath the Big Pine Reservation is eighty feet. There is not a single living tree or bush with roots that long. Nothing can survive here without an application of surface water.”
Noah carries forward the legacy of two men: Alan Bacock, his predecessor as the Water Program Coordinator for the Big Pine Paiute Tribe of the Owens Valley, and his late and much-admired father, Harry Williams, a water warrior who narrated the movie Paya: The Water Story of the Paiute.
“My father told me about places that no longer exist,” Williams said. “He documented DWP’s removal of cottonwood stumps that provided evidence of the cottonwood forest that used to be scattered up and down the valley. Once DWP started to divert water away from these areas to the aqueduct and later the groundwater pumping, (that) is what led to the loss of this resource. Many of these areas were lost to fire in the 1970's, some of the most notable areas where these forests existed are near the Owens River and the Sunland Indian Allotments.
“DWP frames the narrative as if they belong here and that the Valley was always dry. It seems they are trying to erase our memories. Our Elders who remember how fertile our home once was are dying off or exhausted from fighting for our water. I grew up playing in the creeks and want my future children to enjoy the same pleasure.”
Indeed, it is difficult to reimagine Big Pine, currently a dusty and bleak land, as verdant with living streams, creeks, meadows, grasses, ponds, lakes, and forests of cottonwood trees. Paya means water in the Paiute language, an offshoot from the Uto-Aztecan language. Central to their culture, water is the root name of their home, Payahuunadü, the land of flowing waters. Known as the Paiute, these people indigenous to the Eastern Sierra, who have long lived in bands of families with unique dialects, refer to themselves as Nüümü, Nuumu or Numa, depending on location.
It is necessary to recognize that, for more than a century, governments and institutions like DWP have attempted to deny American Indian peoples their unique cultures and traditions. Beginning in the 1880s through the mid 1900s, American Indian children were forcibly taken from their homes and made to assimilate in institutional schools, such as Stewart Indian School in Carson City, Nevada, and Sherman Indian High School in Riverside, California. Here in the Eastern Sierra, Indigenous people have been deprived of their cultural heritage related to water, resulting in economic hardship, collapse of community health, and extreme disadvantage for building generational wealth.
“There needs to be some accountability from LADWP for the ecological disasters they created up and down the Valley.” Williams said. “Restoring the wetlands at Fish Springs, where now there is a hatchery, is a start."
Coming up: Do you know how a fish hatchery in Owens Valley works? Find out the mechanics, tourism and ecological sustainable solutions in the next issue of Every Last Drop.